Judge: Trump can’t sue NYT for speculating about his ties to Russia

Recently Updated

Top Folders

Dates on Trump File reflect when something happens, not when it's first reported.

Manhattan state Supreme Court Judge James d’Auguste dismisses a lawsuit by the Trump campaign against the New York Times. The campaign had argued that an op-ed about Trump’s allegiance with the Russian government during 2016 qualifies as defamation.

The judge’s dismissal is with prejudice, meaning the lawsuit cannot be filed again.

Donald J. Trump for President Inc. claimed that the New York Times published the op-ed with intent to damage Trump’s re-election chances, and they wanted the publisher to pay the campaign millions in damages.

According to the ruling, the Times piece is protected speech. But even if it wasn’t, d’Auguste notes, the campaign’s case has other flaws.

  1. Since the article is in the opinion section of the newspaper, the Times made clear that the context was not intended to be viewed as fact.
  2. A “necessary element” for defamation cases is that the plaintiff is the victim of the alleged defaming. The New York Times does not accuse the Trump campaign — the plaintiff — of any wrongdoing.
  3. If the above statements did not apply, the ruling would stay the same because the campaign is unable to prove that there was intent to damage Trump’s re-election chances.

A federal judge dismissed a similar case against CNN in November because for the third reason above.

External Sources

CNBC (Archived)

The New York Times (Archived)

Photo:

Note From TF

Some Trump File posts are incomplete as the site is still young and Trump world moves fast. Please use the source links to read further if a topic interests you or if you doubt its authenticity. If a post does not have source links, it is an early draft and will be updated soon. I plan to go back and build on every post in the future.

If If there is content you'd like to add context to or something that should be corrected, please contact TF by clicking here or email us at trumpfile@protonmail.com. You can also find us on Twitter.

Support The Site:

Keep Reading

Recommended

Dates on Trump File reflect when something happens, not when it's first reported.

Manhattan state Supreme Court Judge James d’Auguste dismisses a lawsuit by the Trump campaign against the New York Times. The campaign had argued that an op-ed about Trump’s allegiance with the Russian government during 2016 qualifies as defamation.

The judge’s dismissal is with prejudice, meaning the lawsuit cannot be filed again.

Donald J. Trump for President Inc. claimed that the New York Times published the op-ed with intent to damage Trump’s re-election chances, and they wanted the publisher to pay the campaign millions in damages.

According to the ruling, the Times piece is protected speech. But even if it wasn’t, d’Auguste notes, the campaign’s case has other flaws.

  1. Since the article is in the opinion section of the newspaper, the Times made clear that the context was not intended to be viewed as fact.
  2. A “necessary element” for defamation cases is that the plaintiff is the victim of the alleged defaming. The New York Times does not accuse the Trump campaign — the plaintiff — of any wrongdoing.
  3. If the above statements did not apply, the ruling would stay the same because the campaign is unable to prove that there was intent to damage Trump’s re-election chances.

A federal judge dismissed a similar case against CNN in November because for the third reason above.

External Sources

CNBC (Archived)

The New York Times (Archived)

Photo:

NOTE FROM TF

Some files are incomplete as the site is still young and Trump world moves fast. Please use the source links to read further if a topic interests you or if you doubt its authenticity. I plan to go back and build on every file in the future.

If there is content you'd like to add context to or something that should be corrected, please contact us by clicking here or email us at trumpfile@protonmail.com

Support The Site:

Keep Reading

Recently Added & Updated

Keep Reading